At an injection moulding plant, a purchasing engineer receives a quotation for 50 plastic housings. Unit price: PLN 38. Injection mould: PLN 27,000. The tooling for an order of fifty parts costs more than the parts themselves. The reaction is always similar: “Why does the mould cost so much?”

The question seems justified, but it misses the point. A mould is neither expensive nor cheap in itself. It is an investment whose economics change depending on how many parts are produced with it. For fifty housings, the mould adds PLN 540 to the cost of each one. For five thousand, it adds just PLN 5.40.

Exactly the same logic governs the economics of industrial graphic overlays: precision-printed front panels that form the top layer of control panels and membrane keypads in machines, electronic devices and HMI systems (Human-Machine Interfaces). There is a one-off cost of production preparation and a recurring cost of manufacturing each unit. Anyone who does not understand this cost structure before sending an RFQ will either overpay for a short production run or negotiate the price in an area where the apparent savings are misleading.

What Makes Up the Tooling Cost?

Manufacturers often list it as a single item in their quotation: “production preparation cost” or an “NRE fee”. The latter abbreviation comes from Non-Recurring Engineering and refers to one-off engineering work. However, a single line in the quotation can conceal several distinct stages, each requiring a real investment of time and resources.

The first is the preparation of technical and design documentation. An engineer analyses the housing drawing, defines the overlay dimensions, positions the openings for buttons and display windows, selects the film material (polyester or polycarbonate), and specifies its thickness, surface finish and type of mounting adhesive. Some of these decisions are made in consultation with the customer; others require independent verification by the manufacturer. The specialist’s working time is included in the tooling cost.

The second stage is manufacturing the cutting die: a physical tool used to cut the finished overlay from a sheet of film into the required shape, with openings made to precisely defined tolerances. A cutting die is made once for a given project. Its cost is borne by the initial order only.

The third component comes into play when the overlay graphics are printed using screen printing. Each printed colour requires a separate screen (a screen-printing stencil), and this is where a trap that buyers are rarely aware of appears. Documentation and the cutting die are strictly one-off costs. Screen preparation, however, is repeated every time production is resumed. Four colours mean four screens. With frequent, small orders, this cost comes back again and again.

A buyer who sees a single line in a quotation reading “NRE: PLN 2,400” has no way of knowing how much of that amount is genuinely one-off and how much will recur with the next order. Yet the distinction between these two categories changes the way purchasing should be planned.

Order Volume vs. Unit Price

The material used for one graphic overlay costs roughly the same whether you order ten units or five hundred. Certified polyester film, mounting adhesive and, where applicable, SMD LEDs. These expenses increase in proportion to the number of units produced. Economists call them variable costs.

For an order of ten overlays, the entire tooling cost (documentation, cutting die, screens and machine changeover time) is spread across ten parts. Each unit carries one-tenth of the initial production-preparation investment. For five hundred units, the same investment is spread across five hundred parts, so each overlay carries just one five-hundredth of the cost. The material price per unit remains identical. The production set-up cost per unit falls fiftyfold.

A manufacturer quoting PLN 380 per overlay for a batch of 10 and PLN 47 per overlay for a batch of 500 is not offering a discount out of goodwill. The quotation reflects how the cost structure changes when production volume absorbs fixed costs.

However, this relationship does not continue indefinitely. Once production capacity reaches its limit, machines may be running three shifts, operators may be working overtime, and processing speeds may force quality compromises. At that point, unit costs can start to rise. The marginal cost curve is not flat. It has a low point, after which it turns upwards.

The Break-Even Point for Small and Large Production Runs

The Break-Even Point (BEP) is the volume at which sales revenue exactly covers costs. Below this point, an order generates a loss; above it, it starts to make a profit.

The standard formula is straightforward:

BEP (units) = Fixed costs ÷ (Unit selling price − Variable cost per unit)

The denominator is the contribution margin: the amount each additional overlay contributes towards covering the production-preparation costs. The higher the contribution margin, the fewer units are needed to break even.

The problem is that, in customised production – where each overlay is designed for a specific device and customer – traditional overhead costing often understates the actual break-even point. Why? Because it does not account for time.

Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing (TDABC) approaches the problem from a different angle. All activities associated with handling a specific batch – plotter configuration, technical consultations with the customer, press changeover and internal logistics – are costed by multiplying the time they take by the cost per minute of the resource involved (machine, workstation or operator). These minutes are treated as fixed costs for that batch and assigned to the specific order. Traditional costing spreads the same costs across all orders as general factory overhead. TDABC assigns them where they actually arise.

What does this mean for a specific order?

Let’s assume a graphic overlay has been priced using traditional overhead costing, with “just under 4% profit per unit”. Once the batch-handling costs are recalculated using TDABC, it turns out that the actual break-even point for this order is almost thirty units. The customer ordered ten. Each unit was theoretically supposed to generate a profit. In reality, the order generated a loss hidden by the way the company allocated indirect costs.

Large production runs behave in the opposite way. At 200, 500 or several thousand units, preparation costs are spread across a large number of parts. Each additional unit moves the result closer to the break-even point and eventually beyond it. Economies of scale come into play, but only once a certain minimum volume has been reached.

A Simplified Cost Calculation

The model below is deliberately simplified. Its purpose is to illustrate proportions, not to provide a production quotation. Only the manufacturer can prepare a reliable quotation based on a specific specification. However, buyers who understand the logic behind these figures ask different questions in their RFQs. Better questions.

Let’s consider two scenarios for the same graphic overlay: a graphic front panel for a machine control panel, measuring 120 × 80 mm, screen-printed in four colours, with a standard cutting die.

Scenario A: Batch of 20 units

  • Technical and design documentation: PLN 800
  • Cutting die: PLN 600
  • Screen preparation (4 colours × PLN 250): PLN 1,000
  • Direct materials (film, adhesive, backing), 20 units × PLN 12: PLN 240
  • Production and changeover time: PLN 480

Total batch cost: PLN 3,120. Unit cost: PLN 156. Tooling costs (NRE + screens) account for PLN 2,400, or 77% of the total.

Scenario B: Batch of 200 units

  • Documentation and cutting die (unchanged): PLN 1,400
  • Screen preparation (unchanged): PLN 1,000
  • Direct materials, 200 units × PLN 12: PLN 2,400
  • Production and changeover time: PLN 1,600 (changeover time remains the same; production time increases, but more slowly than the number of units)

Total batch cost: PLN 6,400. Unit cost: PLN 32. The share of tooling costs falls to 37.5%.

The price of one overlay has fallen almost fivefold. Material and labour costs per unit have changed very little. What has changed is how the initial investment is distributed across the number of parts.

The proportions depend on project complexity, the number of colours, the type of film and the shape of the cutting die. The underlying mechanism, however, is consistent: the shorter the production run, the greater the share of costs that have nothing to do with the part itself.

Order Volume or Order Frequency?

Buyers typically face two options: place a larger order at once to reduce the unit price, or order smaller batches more frequently to limit the amount of capital tied up in inventory.

The answer depends on the technology used by the manufacturer. If the supplier prints overlays using screen printing, every production run requires the screens to be prepared again. Four colours, four screens, every time. Press and assembly workstation changeovers also take time. With this technology, frequent small orders multiply costs that could be avoided by placing one larger order. In this case, negotiating volume makes sense.

The situation changes dramatically when the manufacturer has digital printing capabilities. Ink is applied directly to the film from a digital file, without any physical stencils. There are no screens to prepare and no recurring tooling costs. The cost of setting up a new batch approaches zero. Buyers can place smaller orders more frequently without additional charges. Smaller batches mean shorter lead times between placing an order and installing the overlay in the target device, lower inventory levels and greater flexibility when introducing design changes between production runs.

There is a third factor buyers rarely consider at the RFQ stage: the integration of design and production systems. When a supplier works in a CAD/CAM environment (Computer-Aided Design and Computer-Aided Manufacturing) and transfers part geometry to a plotter or cutting machine without manually re-entering parameters, batch preparation time is reduced to a minimum. Such a manufacturer can handle short runs just as efficiently as long ones.

When requesting a quotation for a membrane keypad or graphic overlay, one of the first questions should concern the printing technology. The answer determines whether the better strategy is to place one large order per year or several smaller ones.

What Does This Look Like at Qwerty?

At Qwerty, cost structure is one of the first topics we discuss with customers. The reason is simple: buyers who understand what they are paying for make better design decisions from the very beginning of the cooperation.

We use digital printing. With this technology, screen preparation – the cost component that recurs with every repeat order in conventional screen printing – is eliminated altogether. The image is transferred directly from a digital file onto the film. The result? The break-even point falls dramatically, making short production runs (a dozen or several dozen units) economically viable – something that would not be cost-effective with screen printing.

We verify the design in a CAD/CAM environment before any physical tooling is made. At this stage, we check:

  • the fit of the graphic overlay to the device housing,
  • the integration of display windows and indicator LEDs,
  • the layout of touch-sensitive areas and their compliance with ergonomic requirements,
  • the selection of sealing solutions to protect the electronics against moisture and contamination,
  • the film’s chemical resistance to substances it will come into contact with during operation.

An error detected in a digital file costs a correction on screen. An error detected after the cutting die has been made costs a new cutting die.

Before moving to serial production, we manufacture a trial batch. The first units undergo testing both at our facility, under laboratory conditions, and at the customer’s site, in the actual operating environment of the device. Only after functionality, fit and durability have been confirmed do we launch the full production order. This protects the budget against a situation in which hundreds of finished overlays turn out to be unusable because of a technical interference that nobody anticipated.

We are the only manufacturer on the Polish market to offer a 36-month warranty on our products. This is possible because we know the parameters of the materials we use and control the process from design to finished part. For a buyer calculating the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) of a panel over the device’s life cycle – the sum of the purchase price, servicing costs and replacement costs over a specified period – a three-year warranty changes the economics of the decision.

Cost Structure as a Buyer’s Tool

The engineer at the injection moulding plant, whose story we began with, did not ask about the mould price because it was too high. He asked because he did not know how to interpret it. Once he understood that a mould for 50 parts and a mould for 5,000 parts are the same mould, but involve a different cost calculation, he started negotiating volume instead of asking for a discount.

The same applies to graphic overlays. A buyer who understands the distinction between one-off and recurring costs before sending an RFQ, knows which printing technology they prefer and can estimate annual demand will ask a different question. Instead of “Why is it so expensive?”, they will ask: “Which parameter can I change to improve the result?” That is a much better question.